1. Wrong: They looked under the bed, and the dresser for the wallet.
Better: They looked under the bed and the dresser for the wallet.
Explanation: The compound object of the preposition under shouldn't be separated by a comma.
2. Wrong: Sally, and Mary said their vows, and left the mosque.
Better: Sally and Mary said their vows and left the mosque.
Explanation: Neither the compound subject (Sally and Mary) nor the compound predicate (said and left) should be separated by commas.
3. Wrong: The boy who won the prize in the Prep Science competition, and the girl who earned the highest mark in English both went on the school's trip to Quebec.
Better: The boy who won the prize in the Prep Science competition and the girl who earned the highest mark in English both went on the school's trip to Quebec.
Explanation: The two parts of this compound subject shouldn't be separated with commas.
4. Correct: After I finished David Levithan's Every Day, I raced to read the sequel.
Explanation: This sentence has no compound elements.
5. Correct: Varsity football, Varsity Field Hockey, Boys Varsity Soccer, and Varsity Volleyball all won championships that fall.
Explanation: A compound subject of more than two items must be separated by commas.